UNIVERSIYT OF MORATUWA SRI LANKA STUDY ON USE OF INFORMATION AND COMMUNICATION TECHNOLOGIES (ICTS) IN TEACHING AND LEARNING PROCESS AT TECHNICAL COLLEGES MASTER OF SCIENCE DEGREE IN OPERATIONAL R E S E A R C H DEPARTMENT OF MATHEMATICS FACULTY OF ENGINEERING H.R.W.P.GUNATHILAKE NOVEMBER 2004 University of Moratuwa 84144 84144 SI 04. STUDY ON USE OF INFORMATION AND COMMUNICATION TECHNOLOGIES (ICTS) IN TEACHING AND LEARNING PROCESS AT TECHNICAL COLLEGES DISSERTATION SUBMITTED BY H.R.W.P.GUNATHILAKE SUPERVISED BY PROF.G.T.F.DE SILVA AND DR. M.INDRALINGAM FOR THE PARTIAL FULFILLMENT O F THE REQUIREMENT FOR THE A W A R D O F M A S T E R O F SCIENCE D E G R E E IN OPERATIONAL R E S E A R C H DEPARTMENT OF MATHEMATICS FACULTY OF ENGINEERING UNIVERSIYT OF MORATUWA SRI LANKA NOVEMBER 2004 TO MY PARENTS TEACHERS AND LECTURERS DECLARATION I certify that this dissertation does not incorporate any material previously submitted for any degree or diploma in any university and to the best of my knowledge and belief it does not contain any material previously published or written or orally communicated by another person except where due reference made in this text. To the best of our knowledge above particulars are correct. H.R.W.P.Gunathilake Prof. G.T F De Silva Supervisor Department of Mathematics Faculty of Engineering University of Moratuwa Sri Lanka Dr. M.Indralingam Supervisor Department of Mathematics Faculty of Engineering University of Moratuwa Sri Lanka iv ACKNOWLEDGEMENT It gives me a great pleasure in placing a record on my sincere thanks a n d gratitude to those who have directly or indirectly involved and contributed at any stage of this dissertation project. This would not be successful without their invaluable and erudite suggestions. I express my heartfelt gratitude to my supervisors Prof. G.T.F.De Silva and Dr.M Indralingam for their expert guidance, suggestions and encouragement to conduct this research in a constructive manner. I am indebted to them for their valuable commitments and advice. I extend my grateful appreciation to all the lecturers who taught during this course of study for fostering the necessary theoretical background, encouragement, guidance and co-operation received. Further I convey thank to the Director General of Department of Technical Education and Training Mr. J Weerasinghe and the Director ( Research and Development) Mr. K.R.G. Gunasinghe for their support in obtaining the necessary data for this research. The questionnaire used in this study and the interviewing required approximately around 4 5 minutes. This research would not have been possible if not for the willing support extended to me b y the Principals, Vice Principals, HODs and the responded academic staff members of the technical colleges. Their co-operation and allocating time for the questionnaire survey is highly appreciated. I extend my sincere gratitude to all the non academic staff members of the Department of Mathematics for the excellent co-operation and all endeavors received. Last but not least I express my heartfelt gratitude to my parents and friends for the understanding, encouragement and assistance extended to me in completing my research study. CONTENTS Chapter Number Descr ip t ion Page Number Chapter 01 Introduct ion 1-13 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6 1. 7 Background Problem Identification Objectives of the Study Methodology Limitations Anticipated Results Future Directions for Further Research Organization of the Study Chapter 02 L i t e r a t u r e Survey 2 5 7 8 9 11 11 12 14-57 2.1 Introduction 15 2.2 Information, Information 15 Technology (IT) and Information and Communication Technology (ICT) 2.3 Purposes of using ICT in 16 Technical Education 2.4 Technology and Learning 16 2.5 Integrating ICT in Technical 19 Education 2.5.1 ICT as a Tool for Students' 20 Learning 2.5.2 Widely Used ICT Capabilities as a 21 Tool in Students' Learning 2.6 Use of Interactive Video in 26 Technical Education and Training 2.6.1 Delivering Individualized 27 Instruction 2.6.2 Types of Video Technology 28 2.6.3 Five Phases of Interactive Video 29 Design 2.6.4 Producing Interactive Video 30 Materials 2.6.5 Using Interactive Video in 31 Instruction vi 2 - 6 - 6 Case Study: Machine Lathe 3 2 Operation 2 7 31 Instructional Application of Computer Games 2 - 8 Using ICT to Assess Students' 3 6 Learning 2.8.1 Different Functions of Assessment 36 2.8.2 Computer Aided Assessment 38 2.8.3 Objective Tests for Computer 41 Assisted Assessment (CAA) 2.9 Computer Based Training (CBT) 43 2.9.1 Computer Assisted Learning (CAL) 44 2.9.2 Computer Managed Learning (CML) 53 2.10 Summary 57 Chapter 03 Development and Present 58-66 s i t u a t i o n of Technical Education 3.1 Introduction 59 3.2 Historical Background 59 3.3 Technical Education at Present 62 3.4 Links with Local and Foreign 64 Institutions 3.4.1 Local Institutions 64 3.4.2 Foreign Institutions 64 3.5 Steps That Have Taken by the 65 Department to Train Academic Staff on ICT Usage 3.6 Present Situation of ICT Usage at 66 Technical Colleges 3.7 Summary 66 Chapter 04 Methodology 67-79 4.1 Introduction 68 4.2 Literature Survey 68 4.3 Questionnaire Design 69 4.4 Factors Considered in 70 Questionnaire Design 4.5 Sample Selection, Data Collection 74 and Limitations of the Questionnaire Survey 4.6 Techniques Used to Analyze Data 78 vii 4.6.1 Qualitative Methods 78 4.6.2 Quantitative Methods 79 4.7 Summary 7 9 Chapter 05 Presentat ion of Data and 80-122 A n a l y s i s of Resul t s 5.1 Introduction 81 5.2 Types of Teaching Materials 81 Provided for Students 5.3 Methods Used for Preparing 84 Teaching Materials 5.4 References Made for Preparing 85 Teaching Materials 5.5 Methods Used for Delivering 87 Lectures 5.6 Methods used for Students 89 Evaluation Methods Used for Preparing 90 5.7 Examination Papers 5.8 Methods Used for Marking Answer 92 Scripts 5.9 Methods Used to Release 93 Exam/Assignment Results 5.10 Methods used to submit the 95 Assignments by students 5.11 Methods Used by Students to Do 96 Their Project/Assignment Presentations 5.12 References Recommended by the 97 Lecturers 5.13 Methods Used by the Students to 98 Find Information about the Course (Syllabuses, Assignment Titles, Exam Dates etc.) 5.14 What do the Students Refer when 99 Writing Assignments? 5.15 Methods Used by Students to 100 Prepare Assignments 5.16 How Do The Students Discuss 100 Problems with Lecturers? 5.17 Level of Lecturers'/Instructors' 102 Skills in Using ICT 5.18 Incentives to Use and Integrate 103 ICT in Teaching and Learning viii y 5.19 Changes in Teaching as a Result 105 of Integrating ICT 5.20 Changes in Students' Learning as 106 a Result of Integrating ICT 5.21 Attitudes on Integrating ICT for 107 Teaching and Learning 5.22 Important Sources for Acquiring 109 Computer Skills 5.23 Important Sources of Support in 111 Using ICT 5.24 Important Sources of Information 112 for Keeping Abreast with Innovations in ICT 5.25 Suggested Improvements and Their 113 Advantages in Using ICT 5.26 Difficulties to Integrate ICT 115 5.27 Respondents' General Information 118 5.28 Respondents' Willingness to 121 Obtain Training on Using ICT 5.29 Summary 122 Chapter 06 Discuss ion of Findings and 123-130 Conclusions 6.1 Introduction 124 6.2 Discussion of Findings 124 6.3 Conclusions 128 6.4 Summary 130 Chapter 07 Suggest ions to Overcome the 131-139 Major D i f f i c u l t i e s in Using ICT a t Technical C o l l e g e s 7.1 Introduction 132 7.2 Shortage of modern teaching and 133 learning resources to use ICT in teaching & learning 7.3 Inadequacy of 138 lecturers'/instructors' competency in ICT usage in teaching & learning 7.4 Summary 139 Chapter 08 Future Trends in Technical 140-155 Education through ICT 8.1 Introduction " 141 8.2 Use of E-Learning 142 8.2.1 Distinct Learning Advantages of 144 E-Learning 8.2.2 Advantages of E-Learning for 145 Technical Education in Sri Lanka 8.3 Use of Virtual Reality 146 8.3.1 Educational Benefits of Using 147 Virtual Reality 8.3.2 Applications of Virtual Reality 148 for Technical Education 8 . 4 Use of Special Software 149 8.4.1 Special Software Used for Civil 150 Engineering Subject Stream 8 . 4.2 Special Software Used for , 151 Mechanical Engineering Subject Stream 8 . 4.3 Special Software Used for 152 Electrical/Electronic Engineering Subject Stream 8 . 4 . 4 Special Software Used for 153 Business Studies Subject Stream 8 . 4.5 Special Software Tools, which can 154 be used in Teaching and Learning in any subject stream 8.5 Summary 155 Chapter 09 Recommendations and 156-159 D i r e c t i o n s f o r Future Research 9.1 Introduction 157 9.2 Recommendations 157 9.3 Directions for Future Research 158 x Appendix 160-177 Appendix 01 References 161-166 Appendix 02 Locat ion of Technical 167 C o l l e g e s Appendix 03 Quest ionnaire 168-174 Appendix 04 Subjec t Components of 175-177 Courses Se lected f o r the Quest ionnaire Survey > xi y F i g u r e N u m b e r Figure 1 . 1 Figure 2.1 Figure 2.2 Figure 2.3 Figure.2.4 Figure 4.1 Figure 5.1 Figure 5.2 Figure 5.3 Figure 5.4 Figure 5.5 Figure 5.6 Figure 5.7 Figure 5.8 Figure 5.9 Figure 5.10 Figure 5.11 Figure 5.12 Figure 5.13 Figure 5.14 LIST OF FIGURES P a g e D e s c r i p t i o n „ . N u m b e r Research Methodology 1 0 Uses of Computers in Education 19 Uses of computer Games in Educational 35 Setting Use of Technology in Assessments 38 A General Model of Computer Managed 56 Learning Cause and Effect Diagram (Fish Bone 79 Diagram) Numbers of Responses for Types of 81 Teaching Materials Provided Percentage of Responses I for Types of 82 Teaching Materials Provided Numbers of Responses for Methods Used 84 for Preparing Teaching Materials Percentages of Responses for Methods 84 Used for Preparing Teaching Materials Percentages of Responses for 86 References Made in Preparing Teaching Materials Numbers of Responses for Methods Used 87 for Delivering Lectures Percentages of Responses for Methods 88 Used for Delivering Lectures Responses for Subjects Evaluation 89 Methods Percentages of Responses for Subjects 90 Evaluation Methods Number of Responses for Methods Used 90 to Prepare Examination Papers Percentages of Responses for Methods 91 Used to Prepare Examination Papers Methods Used for Marking Answer 92 Scripts Categorized Responses for Methods 92 Used for Marking Answer! Scripts Number of Responses for Methods Used 93 to Release Exam/Assignment Results xii y Figure 5.15 Figure 5.16 Figure 5.17 Figure 5.18 Figure 5.19 Figure 5.20 Figure 5.21 Figure 5.22 Figure 5.23 Figure 5.24 Figure 5.25 Figure 5.2 6 Figure 5.27 Figure 5.28 Figure 5.29 Figure 5.30 Figure 5.31 Figure 5.32 Figure 5.33 Figure 5.34 Percentage of Responses for Methods 94 Used to Release Exam/Assignment Results Responses for Methods Used by 96 Students to Do Their Project/Assignment Presentations Responses for References Recommended 97 by the Lecturers Methods Used by the Students to Find 98 Information about the Course References Made by Students 99 How Do the Students Discuss the 101 Problems with Lecturers? Level of Lecturers'/Instructors' 102 Skills in Using ICT (a) Incentives to Use and Integrate 104 ICT in Teaching and Learning (b) Incentive to Use and Integrate 105 ICT in Teaching and Learning (a) Attitudes on Integrating ICT for 108 Teaching and Learning (b) Attitudes on Integrating ICT for 109 Teaching and Learning Important sources for Acquiring 110 Computer Skills Important Sources of Support in Using 111 ICT (a) Important Sources of Information 112 for Keeping Abreast with Innovations in ICT (b) Important Sources of Information 113 for Keeping Abreast with Innovations in ICT Cause and Effect Diagram for Barriers 116 in Integrating ICT Numbers of Respondents from Technical 118 Colleges Respondents' Educational Background 120 Willingness to Obtain Training on 121 Using ICT Types of Training Respondents Like to 122 Get xi i i Y T a b l e N u m b e r Table 1.1 Table 2.2 Table 4.1 Table 4.2 Table 4 . 3 Table 5.1 Table 5.2 Table 5.3 Table 5.4 Table 5.5 Table 7.1 Table 8.1 Table 8.2 Table 8.3 Table 8.4 LIST OF TABLES D e s c r i p t i o n ISTE's New Learning Environments Different Kinds o f Assessment That can be Used with Computers Selected Technical Colleges for the Questionnaire Survey Summary of the Questionnaire Distribution Format Used in MS Excel to Enter the Data for Analysis Responses for Types of References Responses for Methods Used to Submit Assignments Methods Used by Students to Prepare Assignments Suggested Improvements and Their Advantages in Using ICT Quantitative Analysis of Responses for Barriers in Integrating ICT List of Items and the Cost Analysis Special Software Used for Civil Engineering Subject Stream Special Software Used for Mechanical Engineering Subject Stream Special Software Used for Electrical/Electronic Engineering Subject Stream Special Software Used for Business Studies Subject Stream xiv V ABBREVIATIONS OHP Over Head Projector MCQ Multiple Choice Questions CAD Computer Aided Drafting A/L Advanced Level A Agree ADB Asian Development Bank CPSC Colombo Plan Staff College for Technical Co­ operation CD - ROMS Compact Discs Read Only Memory CAA Computer Assisted Assessment CAL Computer Assisted Learning CAI Computer Assisted Training CAT Computer Assisted Training CBI Computer Based Instructions CBL Computer Based Learning CBT Computer Based Training CMI Computer Managed Instructions CML Computer Managed Learning CMT Computer Managed Training CAI Computer Assisted Instruction CAV Constant Angular Velocity DA Disagree ICT Information and Communication Technology IT Information Technology ISD Institute for Studies in Education ISD Instructional Systems Design ILS Integrated Learning Systems ISTE International Society of Technology in Education's JICA Japan International Co-operation Agency LA Little Agree NCAT National Certificate in Accounting Technicians NCCA National Certificate in Computer Applications NCDA National Certificate in Draughtsmanship Apprenticeship NCIT National Certificate in Industrial Technicians OMR Optical Mark Reader SA Strongly Agree SD Strongly Disagree WWW World Wide Web xv r ABSTRACT Technical education system produces technical manpower of different competency profiles. The pass outs mainly work in industrial, business and training institutions. Some students become entrepreneurs by setting up their own enterprise. The courses offered by the technical colleges need to be market driven. The teaching and learning process is the core function of the technical colleges. In the modern world that changes rapidly with the evolution of new technologies, the ways of training should be modernized with the emerging trends of ICT. So this study aims to ascertain the u s e of ICT for the teaching and learning process at technical colleges. The objectives of this study are: • To study the present level of using ICT for teaching and learning process at technical colleges. • Identify the activities of the teaching learning and process that ICT can be used and the ways in which ICT can be incorporated into these activities. • To identify the advantages of using ICT over the existing methods used for the teaching and learning process. • To identify the difficulties in using ICT for teaching and learning process at technical colleges and to propose suitable solutions to overcome these difficulties. The study was carried out mainly through questionnaire survey and interviews to achieve the above objectives. It provided the opportunity to identify the present status of using ICT for the teaching and learning process. It also helped to identify the future trends in technical education through ICT. The major two problems identified are the lack of resources and the lack of competence of academic staff members in using ICT for the teaching and learning process. The two suggestions forwarded are to initiate instructional resource centers and to introduce pedagogical license on ICT usage to encourage the academic staff on using ICT for teaching and learning. xvi The major future trends ICT usages are on interactive technical education programs on Internet and World Wide Web. The need for using new technologies in technical education with the potential of ICT such as web based learning and e-learning are identified as the ways of providing the technical education to a larger target group than present traditional methods. Finally this study provided the opportunity to come up with recommendations which will be useful for enhancing the teaching and learning process by integrating ICT. This study aimed at only one function of technical colleges; its leaching and learning process. Therefore further studies should be carried out on the ways of using ICT for other functions at technical colleges such as administrative, quality assurance, career guidance and student counseling, social marketing, curriculum development, student evaluation etc. It will be much helpful to provide market driven technical education for the youngsters of our nation to meet the challenges in the twenty first century. xvii