I t V Chapter Five Chapter Five Conclusions and Recommendations This Chapter sets out t bring forward several general conclusions with regards to the role of the Design Dimension in Town Planning or Urban Development Planning, and the potential indicators, variable and methods in capturing the same discussed in this Study. Moreover, based on the findings of the Study several General and Case Study Specific Recommendation with regards to the incorporation of the Design Dimension to the Planning Process were evolved. 5.1 Conclusions Design Dimension, it can be rightfully claimed, is an integral part of Town/City Planning as the formulation and articulation of the spatial framework for integrated development is the ultimate focus of any Town Development Plan. In other terms, the final outcomes of any Town Plan are with spatial implications in the nature of additions, modifications, preservation, improvements etc. to an existing spatial frame work of an area concerned. Hence, Town Plans prepared disregarding the Design Dimension, it can be justifiably said, would not make holistic towns/cities. In fact, this study stresses the idea that Town Planning should, from the inception, be a Spatial Design Exercise. This study promotes a Town or a City as the main Sensuous Framework - visual, aural, olfactory and tactile framework - which provides the base for all endeavors of man - his socio-cultural and spatial behaviour. Every Town/City (or any micro/macro, natural/man-made environmental unit) has its own unique sensuous framework, which is identified and promoted as the 'Character' of that, which in turn forms the base for the Design Dimension of it. Design dimension of an environment, thus, is not merely concerned with beauty as is misconceived by many in the planning field; it is much more concerned with the integration of all aspects related to people and their living environment. The social importance of an environment (be it a Town/City, Rural Area or a part of it) having a unique and good sensory quality (which is the direct manifestation and interpretation of the sensuous framework/Character/ Design Dimension of it) recognized world-widely as it is the responsive attribute of any environment which, © promotes the sense of belonging towards its users directly and indirectly improving their productivity, o provide a democratic setting towards its users which contributes to maximize the 'choice' available. Capturing and incorporation of the Design Dimension of an environment - Town/City - is said to affect 'Public Choice' in several ways; According to Alcock, B. & McGlynn, S. Smith, G. Murrain, P. (1985) it affects, o where people can go and where they cannot (only places which are accessible to people can offer them choice), o range of uses available to people (availability of Variety of Uses or Diverse Environments) ° how easily people can understand what opportunities are in offer (how legible an environment is / how easily people can understand the structure of an environment), o the degree to which people can use a given environment for different purposes (availability of places which can be used for many different purposes), o Whether the detailed appearance of an environment makes people aware of the choices available, o Peoples choice of sensory experiences, o The extent to which people can put their own stamp on an environment Hence, it is strongly stressed that the proper capturing, understanding and addressing of the unique Design Dimension / Character of an environment - a Town/City - is of vital importance in any Town Planning Exercise. It was observed, in this s tudy , that the current Town Planning Approaches in Sri Lanka do not accommodate the Design Dimension of an environment in a holistic wav. A l t h o u g h the o u t c o ' n *s of the Town Plan are mostlv design related - Land U s e 131 Zoning, Density Zoning. Deveh-'^rrnt C". ; • Plans, Planning and Building Regulations - , at the Survey and Analysis stages, consideration is given to conventional physical, economic, social environmental data in a non-spatial way. There happen to be several obvious reasons for such drawbacks in the current Town Planning Process in Sri Lanka. One reason is directly related to the education and training of Town Planners in Sri Lanka. Though reviewing Town Planning education is not the specific aim of this study, it should be highlighted that the fifteen hour exposure to Urban Design for post graduate students in Town Planning (majority of them coming from fields not allied to design) is not in the least sufficient for them to start even sensing the environment in a design oriented way. It is thought too early to review the undergraduate education in Town Planning (as it was commenced only very recently); however, the incorporation of Design related studies can be recognized as a positive attempt towards overcoming the above identified drawback. At the practice level also, most of the town plans are prepared without the positive incorporation of the Design Dimension. Normally, Urban Design inputs are considered at the proposal stage at the level of action projects and the involvement of the urban designer is sought at that stage. Even in the instances where an Urban Designer is involved in plan preparation from the initial stages, the town planner and the urban designer (and others such as the transport planner, social planner etc.) work more or less in isolation meeting and brainstorming occasionally. Both these could be called piecemeal approaches as they do not have the full probability of considering Design Dimension as an integral part of a Town Plan in all related aspects from the inception. The writer, thus acknowledges and supports the idea of many scholars/researches in the field of Urban Planning/Urban Design that Town Planning should be seen as a spatial Design Exercise; the Design Dimension should be considered an integral part of a Town Plan from the inception and the Town Planner should be competent and skilled to capture, understand and 132 address the Design Dimension of an environment in Survey, Analysis/Synthesis and Proposal! stages of a Town Plan. This focus us on main reason for the drawbacks in the positive incorporation of Design Dimension - the non-availability of easily comprehensible, easily applicable criteria and methods to grasp the Design Dimension of Town/City, proposing potential answers for which was attempted in this study. The study identified the constituents (Spatial Form and Its Accompanying Conditions, Visible Life and Activity and Meaning) and Causative Factors (associated Historical and Cultural Aspects, Functional and Geographical aspects) of Character of a Town/City which were interpreted as the Indicators and Variables of Design Dimension of it. The nature, characteristics, performance and contribution of these indicators individually and collectively in manifesting the Design Dimension of a Town/City was further established. While acknowledging the fact that there exist more potential, more developed and more comprehensive methods for studying the Design Dimension of a Town/City, the study promoted the adoptability of two commonly used Survey methods - the Field Reconnaissance Survey and the Public Perception Survey - and Analysis Methods - SWOT Analysis and Graphical Spatial Analysis - in the Planning Process in Sri lanka, to address the Design Dimension of a Town/City. The appropriateness of the Indicators and variables of Design Dimension identified and the applicability of the methods in capturing the Desing Dimension was further strengthened through the application of the same in a Case Study Area - Panadura Town Center. Based on the findings of both literature analysis on the Design Dimension, the process followed and the findings of the Case Study certain general and case specific recommendations could be formulated. 5.2 Recominnieirndatioinis Recommendations are given mainly in two forms; ° General Recommendations •> .;z Study Specif:J T>.eco..,.mc.idati. General recommendations cover planning education, planning practice and general recommendations related to addressing the Design Dimension of an environment. 5.2.1 General Recommendations — Planning Education o Town Planning should be considered and approached mainly as a Spatial Design Exercise and the Design Dimension of a Town/City should be considered as an integral part of it in relation to its social, physical economic and environmental aspects. o Sensing, studying an environmental unit - regardless being a micro environment such as a neighborhood , housing scheme etc. or a micro environmental unit such as a Town/City or a part of it - in a design oriented way should be the base of any Town Planning / Town Design exercise. In this orientation it is recommended to, o Consider Design Dimension as a core area of Study both in Post graduate studies in Town Planning, Urban Development, Land Use Planning, Housing Development Planning and Housing development etc. and, Undergraduate studies in Town Planning. o Include education related to Design Dimension of an Environment as a foundation subject which continues incrementally throughout the Post Graduate study Course/s. o Recognize, Spatial Design as a core subject that includes and address all the main aspects of Town Planning at undergraduate level and to provide opportunities to give adequate practical exposure for the students on the related aspects and complexities of Design Dimension of an environment. o Positively incorporate, at both Postgraduate and Undergraduate levels, the Design Dimension related skill development - Graphical Communication ;!v ../ling t ; i d ;:ec!inical drawing), 3-D . ' p . g , pho.^graphy, videography, computer aided drawing, spatial information systems, computer based recording and analysis methods etc. especially in relation with integrated project exercises. Adopt Field Reconnaissance Survey and Public Perception Survey Methods as potential methods of Survey which can absorb Design Dimension of an environment in all its related aspects. Adopt SWOT Analysis and Graphical Spatial Analysis Methods as potential Methods of Analysis of Design Dimension in all its related Aspects. Sieve Map Technique also could be adopted as a potential Graphical Analysis Method for this purpose. Search for opportunities for the Geographic Information System to be used as a potential and more scientific tool for spatial analysis in relation to Design Dimension of an environment. 'Space Syntax' Technique introduced and practiced in United Kingdom (Prof. Bill Hillier, Bartlett School of Graduate Studies, University College, London) also would be a highly potential tool for the study of Design Dimension of an environment. Numerous further research avenues, with regards to the o Nature, characteristics, performance, inter-relationships and contributions of the main and sub-indicators of Design Dimension identified o the potential methods of Survey and Analysis of Design Dimension o Design Products o Implementation Mechanisms (financial, legal, administrative) of Design have enormous potential to evolve and develop in Sri Lanka, parallel to already established research avenues in many countries in the world. Therefore, the establishment of an Urban Design Research Base in the Faculty of Architecture shall be a positive as well as essential step forward in this regard. 5.2.2 General! R e c o m m e n d a t i o n s - P lann ing Prac t ice o Urban Design function should be under the guidance and supervision of a single body such as the Urban Development Authority which will link up with the local government bodies in preparing urban planning/design proposals. o Urban Design shall be considered as a part of Local Government function and shall be incorporated into the administrative framework of the local Government thus ensuring the effective preparation, implementation, monitoring and management of the Design Proposals. o Each local government body shall form an Urban Planning/Design Unit either individually or in collaboration with private Urban Design Group headed by a Director (Planning/Design) which in turn shall work together with the central body in preparation and management of Urban Design proposals for the particular area. o Deployment of highly competent and skillful Town Planners with a good design sense at local government level shall be of vital importance. o Town Planning Professionals currently in practice should be exposed to the Design Aspect of Town Planning together with related skill development through well developed intensive training programmes. o Methods should be developed and introduced especially to the Local Government Bodies in order to maintain regular records on the Design Dimension (the characteristics related to the Spatial Form and accompanying conditions, Visible Life and Activity and Meaning) of the particular local area. 136 5.2.3 Genera l R e c o m m e n d a t i o n s - To Addres s the Design Dimension of a Town/Ci ty o Spatial Design Process can be conceptualized as follows; Field Reconnaissance Survey Literature Survey Public Perception Survey Geographical Aspects <5-t> I Spatial Form and its Accompanying Conditions 1 Visible Life and Activity Functional Aspects Meaning I Historical and Cultural Aspects SWOT Analysis/ Graphical Analysis Identification of opportunities and Limitations with regards to the Design Dimension Monitoring and Feed Back Conceptual Design (Formulation of Vision. Goals and Objectives) I Alternative Spatial Design Strategies Evaluation & selection of the Potential Design Strategy Policies Plan (< > 1 Guidelines Programmes V o Proposals related to Design Dimension of an Environment shall come out as, o Policies - General framework for the preparation of Spatial Strategies o Plan - Three dimensional depiction of Spatial Design Policies o Guidelines - Design framework to address specific units of the Spatial Form suggested by the Plan o Programs - framework to improve, maintain and preserve the existing as well as the environments that will be created. (Shirvani, H. 1985, pp. 1 4 4 - 153) o Urban Design Policies shall cover areas such as, o Policies related to spatial design process o Policies related to Implementation, Monitoring and Feed Back policies related to administrative mechanism, policies related to financial mechanisms, policies related to legislative mechanisms o Policies related to Urban Design shall cover the following areas; o Perceptual Identity o Arrangement of general spatial structure o Building Form and Massing o Use of Land Marks o Character Zoning o Land Use / Activity Zoning o Circulation and Parking o Organization of Signage o Conservation o Special Districts -> Usage of Materials o Landscaping => Any other matter significant to the particular area considered 138 o Urban Design Guidelines shouid be prepared to address the policy framework and the spatial proposals indicated in the Urban Design Flan and should include following features; o Purpose and objectives of the guidelines, o Classification of major and minor issues to be covered, o Applicability, o Examples Illustrating some applications (Shirvani, H. 1985, p. 152) L2.4 Specific Recommenda t ions - To A d d r e s s the Design Dimension of the C a s e Study Area ( P a n a d u r a Town) A brief out line of Policies are prepared in conjunction with the Conceptual Urban Design Proposal (Map 5.1.1) prepared for the Pandura Urban Area under the items identified as per the General Design Recommendations; o Perceptual Identity Panadura has a latent Identity related to its history and the religious background. Furthermore it has high potential of creating identity in relation to its natural environment (the river and the sea) which in turn is significantly connected to the historical evolution of the Town. Thus the Urban Design proposals prepared for Panadura should be based on the emphasis of the spatial environment related to its historical / socio-cultural significance and the u n i q u e natural element present. o Arrangement of General Spatial Structure The general spatial s t ruc tu re o f the Town - the organization pattern o f paths, nodes and open s p a c e s wil l be restructured to, 1) Incorporate the presence o f river and sea front into the town through the provision o f physical and visual links at potential locations as defined in the Map 5.1.1 2) M a x i m i z e the v isual l inks w i t h the Water Body enhancing the 'Visual Corridors' by means of widening several identified paths > def ined in Map 5.1.1 3) Maximize legibility within the Urban Area by introducing, extending, straightening and enhancing several identified paths as defined in Map 5.1.1 4) Identify and Emphasize potential nodes as point of orientation and point of perceptual identity. Detailed Design Guide lines with regards to the above will be formulated Building Form and Massing Building Form and Massing shall ensure that the built form of the town slopes down and ease out from the Galle Road towards the water body and towards inland (as defined in Map 5.1.1 and depicted in Figure 5.1). Design Guidelines with regards to the following shall be formulated - Plot Structure/Plot Size, Plot Coverage and Building Heights etc. Use of Land Marks Special attention shall be given to preservation of existing historically, socially, aesthetically and perceptually significant Landmarks in the Town Area and to ensure and emphasize their legibility. Meaningful Land marks shall be established in association with the main nodes and public spaces (as defined in Map 5.1.1) in the Town. Wherever possible, measures to be taken to identify, emphasize and/or establish landmarks which represent the historical and cultural significance which is the base of the identity of Panadura. Character Zoning Fourteen Zones of different character identified (as per Map 4.3.3 and Plates 4.18 - 4.30a) in the town area shall be preliminary identified for conservation, enhancement, improvement/Control or total re-development or re-generation as follows; 140 District Nature of Classification Development IVIIeasure/s District - 4 • _ . . , , . „, i Positive Unique Charactensties Distr ict -8 District - 9 I . , . . , • ! Enhancement ;• ••••• : Improvement needed to emphasize D ! s t n c t 1 1 ! Character D i s t n c t - 1 4 I Distr ict -2 } i Somewhat Positive Character „. . , I Control of negative use of ! , . , „ . , D i s t n c t - 6 , . _ . T. ... , , | Improvement / Control ; arclutectural detailing and adverse i use of Material District - 1 District - 3 Positive Characteristics in relation to historical significance, unique spatial concepts and architectural detailing Unique Characteristics present only in certain parts of the District as the district is undergoing speedy changes in terms of modern spatial concepts, use of modern technology and material in adverse ways etc. Conservation Improvement/Control District - 7 District - 10 District - 112 District - 13 Negative Characteristics (degraded, undcr/un developed and disorderly environments) which threatens the aesthetics associated with the town Introduction of positive characteristics needed i Rc-devclopmcnt I Re-generation District - 5 Somewhat Positive Characteristics in terms of residential activities Improvement need for enhancement of positive characteristics Potential to introduce new character in relation to recreation activities Enhancement Improvement Large Scale Residential buildings of Historical and Architectural Significance Positive Unique Characteristics Conservation Improvement / Control However, final classification of the above shall be based on a detailed study of their characteristics and associated spatial, functional, social, political, legislative aspects. Specific Characteristics to be promoted by each District or group of Districts shall be identified taking into account their present and 141 future functional and responsive roles and Detailed Guidelines shall be prepared to ensure the identified characteristics. Character zoning shall be worked out in conjunction with the Land Use/Activity Zoning. Land Use /Activity Zoning The Town Area shall be identified under several main Land Use Zones (as defined in Map 5.1.1) as follows; Primary Residential Zone Mixed Residential Zone Mixed Development Zone Civic Activity Zone Commercial Zone Special Development Zone Recreational Zone Specific Design Guidelines for permitted uses, plot sizes, building densities shall be worked out in conjunction with the Building Form and Massing and Character Zoning. Circulation and Parking Circulation and Parking patterns will be revised in order to minimize spatial congestion, negative visual impact on the Town Form and also to promote a conducive environment for pedestrians and pedestrian related activity as follows; 1) Pedestrianize parts of the town where high intensity of commercial activities are present as defined in Map 5.1.1 2) Provide Parking under 'Multiple Use Programme', 'Package Plan Parking' and/or 'Urban Edge Parking around the pedestrianized area of the town as defined in Map 5.1.1 3) Establish positive links between the two main public transport modes - the Road Transportation and Railway Transportation through, 142 a. Concentrating Private and CTB Transportation to one location, b. Establishing strong pedestrian links from the Bus Terminal to the Railway Terminal, c. Introducing Road Transportation Services to the Town Centre through a traffic plan ® Organization of Signage Advertising hoardings and signage will not be permitted in sensitive areas such as, Identified Conservation or Historical Areas and visually obstructing historical elements, Visually Obstructing areas of scenic beauty and visual linkage, At the principal nodes of the Town, "HF/^ Existing traditional housing areas and proposed housing areas. Obscuring significant architectural detail I?' Disturbing important traffic signage Outside of these areas well designed advertising hoardings will be acceptable and encouraged. Shop fronts and their signage shall be designed in sympathy with the buildings of which they form part and with their surroundings and in accordance with the shop front guidelines prepared and approved by the Director (Planning) of the Local Government Body. Advertising signage may, however, be acceptable if well designed and formulated with respect for the scale and character of the building on which it is to be displayed; providing it does not detract from the surrounding area and is not out of scale with existing permanent development. Every opportunity will be taken to encourage the display of well designed and well made signs on commercial premises so as to provide additional colour, interest and life into the Town Centre especially during the night. {adopted from Glasgow Central Area Local Plan, Urban Design Policies, 1990 as cited Carmona, C. 1998) 143 Conservation Areas, elements, feature (both natural and man-made) of historical, cultural, locational, functional, architectural and visual significance shall be identified based on a detailed study in conjunction with character and activity zoning, and listed for Conservation. Specific guidelines shall be prepared for the conservation, improvement, re­ vitalizing and maintenance of so identified areas in harmony with activity and character zoning guidelines. Special Districts Districts of Unique Character or Function or both which overlay on one or more existing land use zoning districts shall be identified as Special Districts for the purpose of protecting and enhancing the special qualities of that area. In the same manner, Districts of specific negative spatial and visual impact which overlay on one or more existing land use or character zoning districts shall be identified as Special Districts for the purpose of re-development, re­ generation, renewal. Furnishings Pedestrian areas and public spaces will be the subject of a consistent design treatment, the principal elements shall be very high quality natural surfacing materials, essential street furniture, Landscaping A programme of strategic Landscaping will be promoted in the Town Centre to extend and strengthen the existing prominent 'Green' Character in certain parts of the Town. Following Landscape opportunities will be pursued, - Emphasize existing boulevard nature of identified paths such as the Northern section of the Main Street and Sri Maha Vihara Road, - Introduce boulevard tree planting on paths identified as visual corridors - Jayathi 11 eke Mawatha, Susantha Mawatha, Mahanama 144 Road and other roads as defined in the Map 5.1.1. - towards the River, - Emphasize the existing presence of Greenery at Main Nodes of entry to the Town, - Encourage Formal Tree Planting along the Main Road in association with the pedestrian Walkways, - Special emphasize to be given to creating sense of greenery in all areas identified for re-development in the Town Centre, - Land along the River to be treated as a 'Green Edge' with strong emphasis on tree planting. Specific Design Guidelines to be prepared for each Zone or part of it to ensure the qualities identified above. 145 S c a l e 1 a u u i a I U V V I I \ v a o ^ o i u u y n i c a / sooo - > . • ; | Map 5.1.1 Spatial Design Proposal Legend Primary Residential Zone Mixed Residential Zone Mixed Development Zone Civic Activity Zone Commercial Zone Special Development Zone Recreational zone Proposed Paths, Nodes Structure m zzz v — • i i Boulevards = Pedestrianized Paths Promanade Parking Areas Landmarks to be Preserved Proposed Landmark Locations Areas/Elements to be Conserved Fig-5 .1 Policy Recommendation Building Form Massing • 1. Antoniades, A C. (1980), Architecture and Allied Design: An Environmental Design Perspective, Kendall / Hunt Publishing Co, Dubuque, Iowa, USA. 2. Appleyard, D. (1976), Planning a Pluralist City: Conflicting Realities in Ciudad Guyana, Massachusetts Institute of Technology Press, United States of America. ISBN 0-262-01044-5. 3. Banerjee, T. and Southworth, M. City Sense and City Design; Writings and Projects of Kevin Lynch, MIT Press, USA. 4. Barnett, J. (1974), Urban Design as Public Policy, Practical Methods for Improving Cities, McGraw-Hill Publication, 1221, Avenue of the Americas, New York, 10020, ISBN 0-07-003766-3 5. Broadbent, J. (1990), Emerging Concepts in Urban Space Design, Van Nostrand Reinhold Company, New York 6. Chadwick, G. (1971) (First Edition) A systems View of Planning: Towards a Theory of the Urban and Regional Planning Process, Pergamon Press Limited, Headington Hill Hall, Oxford OX3 OBW, England. ISBN 0-08-020625-5 7. Chalfant, H. P. and Labeff, E. (1988), Understanding People and Social Life: Introduction to Sociology, West Publishing Co, 50w, Kellogg Boulevard, P.O.Box 645226, St, Paul, MN 55164- 1003, ISBN 0-314-28603-9. 8. Ching, F. D. K. (1979), Architecture Form Space and Order, Van Nostrand Reinhold Co, 135, West 50 , h Street, New York, N Y 10020, USA. ISBN 0-442-21534-7 9. Greed, C. and Roberts, M. eds. (1998), Introducing Urban Design: Interventions and Responses, Addison, Wesley Longman Ltd, Edinburgh Gate, Harlow, Essex CM 20 2 JE, England. 10. Howard, E. (1985), Garden Cities of Tomorrow, Attic Books 13, Salisbury Road, East Bourne, East Sussex, BN 20 7UB. 148 11. Jenson, R. (1974), Cities of Vision, Applied Science Publishers Ltd, Ripple Road, Barking, Essex, England. ISBN 085334 569 4 12. Knox, P. and Ozolius, P. (2000), Design Professionals and the Built Environment: An Introduction, John Wiley and Sons Ltd, Baffin's Lane, Colchester, West Sussex P019 1UDUK. 13.Kostof, S. (1991), The City Shaped: Urban Patterns and Meanings Through History, Thames and Hudson Ltd, London 14. Kostof, S. (1992), The City Assembled: Elements of Urban Form through History, Thames and Hudson Ltd, London. 15. Lawson, B. (1980), How Designers Think, The Architectural Press London, ISBN 0 85139 8529 16. Lynch, K. (1978 - Third Edition), Managing a Sense of a Region, Massachusetts Institute of Technology Press, United States of America. ISBN 0-262-1207-0 17. Lynch, K. (1985 - Forth Print), Good City Form, Massachusetts Institute of Technology Press, United States of America. ISBN 0-262- 62046-4. 18. Mc Cluskey, J. (1979, 1992 - Second Edition), Road Form and Townscape, Butterworth-Heinmaun Ltd, Lincare House, Jordan Hill, Oxford OX28DP. 19. Mc Connell, S. (1981), Theories of Planning: An Introduction, William Heinemann Ltd, 10, Upper Grosoenor Street, London. W1X 9 PA, 434 91236 0 20. Morris, A. E. J. (1979 - First Published 1974), History of Urban form before the Industrial Revolutions, George Godwin Limited, the Book Publishing Subsidiary of the Builders Group. 1-3 Pemberton Row Fleet Street, London EC4. 149 21.Norberg Shultz, C. (1980), Genius Loci, Towards a Phenomenology of Architecture, Rizzoli International Publications Inc, 300, Park Avenue South, New York NY 10010. 22. Rapaport, A. (1977), Human Aspects of Urban Form: Towards a Man- Environment Approach to Urban Form and Design, Pergamon Press Inc, Maxwell House, Fairview Park, Elmsford, New York, 10523, USA. ISBN 0-08-017974-6. 23. Roberts, M. (1974), An Introduction to Town Planning Techniques, Hutchinson & Co Publishers, Ltd, 17-21, Conway Street, London. WfP 6 JP ISBN 0-09-116891-0 24. Rossy, A. (1992 - Seventh Print), The Architecture of the City, Massachusetts Institute of Technology Press, United States of America. ISBN 0-262-68043-2. 25. Shirvani, H. (1985), The Urban Design Process, Van Nostrand Reinhold Company Inc, Molly Millers Lane, Wokingham, Berkshire, RG11 2P7, England, ISBN 0-442-28064-5 26. Webber, M. (1958), Translated and Edited by Martindale, D. and Neuwirth, G. (First Free Press Paper Back Edition 1066) The City, The Free Press, A Division of Mc Millan Publishing Co, Inc, 866, Third Avenue, New York, 10022. 1 5 0 Perception Survey 0111 ttRnc Role of Design Dimension an Urban Planning For the M.Sc. (Town and Country Planning) Dissertation - 2002 /. Details of Interview Serial No. Date of Interview Time of Interview Place of Interview 2. Details of the Person Interviewed ° Name ° Professional Qualifications D Professional Experience ° Academic Background m Undergraduate • Post Graduate 3. In your opinion, what is the relationship between Town/City Design and Town/City Planning? (b) If so why? 4. In your opinion, what are the components of a town through which its design dimension is manifested? 5. What is the normal procedure you/your organization follow to address the design dimension of a town/city in preparation of a Town/City Development Plan? (Please give a descriptive account on the a) Methodology adopted, b) parameters used, ways and means of collection and recording of relevant data and the process of evolving design solutions) 6. IVhat are the shortcomings and problems associated with the above-discussed process? 7. (a) Do you believe that a Town Planner should have a good 'design' sense? Yes/No. (b) If so, why? 151 8. (a) In your opinion, is there a need for an established set of parameters, a methodology and a choice of techniques to address the design dimension, particularly in the urban analysis? Yes/No. (b) If so, why? 9. What are the words 'character' and 'identity' means to you? 10. (a) Do you think that it is important for a person to have a unique 'character' and 'identity'? Yes /No. (h) If so, why? 11. In your opinion, through what attributes the 'character/identity' of a person is manifested? 12. Do you think that an environment, be it urban/rural, village/town/cityhnetropolitan - has it's own character and identity? 13. (a) Do you think that people are affected by the characteristics of the environment they live or work in? Yes/No. (b) If yes, please give your opinion as to how people sense the surrounding environment? (c) What sort of characteristics of an environment normally people could sense? (d) If no, please explain as to why do you think so? 151 PMMDC Perception Survey on tine Sensory Quality of the Town/City For the M.Sc. (Town & Country Planning) Dissertation - 2002 /. Details of the Person Interviewed a Name 0 Place of Living/Address • Profession/lJvelihood • Place of Work / School Attending • Age: ° Male /Female a ° Ethnicity Sinhala / Tamil / Muslim Other (specify) 8 Religion Buddhist /Hindu / Catholic /Islam Other (specify) • Mode of Travel to Work/ School Bus Train Personal Vehicle Walking Other • Educational Attainment University Other Higher Studies A/L/ O/L Below O/L (specify) 2. How long have you been associating with Panadura? 3. What first comes into your mind when Panadura is mentioned? (Try to get an idea about the physical quality of the town as a whole) 4. In your opinion what is special about your town ? 5. What is the area you relate to as the Town Centre of Panadura? 6. Where do you sense as the 'entry' and 'exit' of the Town Center (relative to your normal journey associated with the Town)? 7. What are the most distinctive areas/locations, elements/features and events of Panadura in your opinion and what are there significant characteristics? Place/activity Significant Charactersitics a Areas/Locations " Elements/Features • Events 1 5 3 8. What arc the most ugly or boring areas/locations, elements/features and events of Panadura in your opinion and what are there significant characteristics? Place/activity Areas/l^ocations/Elements/Features/Events Significant Characteristics 9. What are the prominent daily activities in the town and what are the areas/locations, elements/features and times associated with them? Activity Location/Area associated with the activity Elements/Features associated with the activity limes associated with the activity 10. What are the prominent seasonal activities in the town and what are the areas/locations, elements/features and times associated with them? Activity Location/Area associated with the activity Elements/Features associated with the activity Times associated with the activity 11. What are the prominent current problems with regards to areas/locations, elements/features and events in the Town ? Area/location, element/feature, event/activity Prominent Problems Associated 12. Name for me the parts of the Town you, Intention Reason P Frequently visit a Would like to visit ° Would dislike to visit 1 5 4 13. Supposing the town is to he changed in the future; What are the areas/locations, elements/features and events of the town, in your opinion, should be preserved in such an action and why? Area /Element/Event Reason 14. Supposing the town is to be changed in the future; What are the areas/locations, elements/features and events in the town, in your opinion, should be changed in such an action, why and what way? Area /Element/Event Reason and suggested change 15. What are the areas/locations, elements/features and events, in your opinion are not fully utilized at present and how can they be more utilized in the future? Area /Element/Event Suggestions for Improvement 16. In what way the Panadura Town has changed during the L Past Year ii Past Five Years UL What changes do you expect to see in the town, during the next five years? 17. What would be the characteristics of your ideal town/city? 18. How do you feel about the town, Like/Dislike/Indifferent Reason 155 Annexture 5-6 Public Perception Survey - Findings Question Duration of Stay Number of Mentioning • Less than 5 Years * * * * * 12% • 5-10 Years * * * * * * * * * 18% o More than 10 Years * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * 70% First thing coming in to mind about Panadura » Panadurawadaya * * 12% » Walana Buddha Statue * * * * 08% o Bo-Tree * o Familier Environment and Known People * * o Good Facilities * o Religion and Culture * " * * 08% o Busy non developed area * * 06% o Lack of Greenary o Market * * * * 10% o Private and CTB Bus Stand * * o Panadura Ground * o Hudson Park * o Hospital * * * * * * * 14% o Rankoth Vihara "V * * * * * * * * 26% o Kethumathi Hospital * * * * * 10% o Banks * o Clock Tower * * * * * * * * * 18% o Railway Station * * 06% o Roundabout o Gunananda Statue * * * * * * * * * 18% o Stagnant Drains and Bad Smell * * o Visual Unpleasantness • ± 06% o Small Town * o CTB Bus Stand * * * 06% o Panadura Grocery * 06% o Fast Developing Town * * o Petrol Shed * o Kovil * o Balika Vidyalaya * o Industrial City * o Janapriya Mawatha * o Private Bus Stand * * * * 08% o Post Office * o Convent * 156 Commercial Area from Bridge to Clock Tower Commercial Bank Church Beach Schools Bridge Town Hall Nothing Special 04 Specialty of the Town • Nothing Special o Town o Religious Middle Class People/ Religion and Culture/ Panadurawadaya Locating Close Proximity to Colombo Splendid Transport Network Central Location of Service Unity of People Large Population Rapid development No Centre Belongingness and Security A Commercial Town A Clean Town Horn Town 05 Town Centre » From Walana Buddha Statue to Sumangala Girl's School o From Gunananda Statue to CTB Bus Stand o Main Street, Janapriya Mawatha and Market Area o Bus Stand, Market, Surrounding Area o Private/ CTB Bs Stands and Surrounding Areas » CTB Bus Stand and the Surrounding Area «> Private Bus Stand and the Surrounding Area Bus Stand, Station and Roundabout near the Clock Tower Gunananda Statue to Walana Bridge Walana Buddha Statue to Gunananda Statue 06 Entry and Exit o Walana Buddha statue * * * * * * 3ft 3$C 3^ E 3fc * * * * * * * * * * * * * 08% 16% 36% 06% 10% 06% 14% 08% 14% 14% 06% 12% 06% 157 50% * * * * o Buddha Statue at Horana Road « Wekada Bus Depot » Clock Tower » Nalluruwa Bridge o Private Bus Stand o Janapriya Mawatha o Railway Bridge o Cargills <» Uyankele © Walana New Bridge «» Moron thuduwa Junction o Nalluruwa Bo-tree «• Nalluruwa Area • Sri Sumangala Girl's school e Hospital o Gunananda Statue o CTB Bus Stand o Panadura Fisheries Harbor ® Unichela o Pinwatta Area o Panadura Grocery Distinctive Areas/ Elements/ Features and their significant characteristics o Panadura Beach- Relaxation o Rankoth Viharaya - Religion /History o Walana Buddha statue - Religion • Panadurawadaya - Religion History • Esplanade and Hudson Park - Sports/ Leisure/ Visual e Modarawila Industrial Complex - Economics © Several Old Buildings - History/Statefulness • Bus Sand - Meeting Point o Gunananda Statue - Histoty » Town Hall o Post Office © Clock Tower - Elements o Railway Station - Transportation « Old Galle Road - Historical Elements and Features o Meeting point of Oldand New Galle Roads - Visually Pleasing a Hospital Junction o Area where the River meets the Sea — Openness/ Relaxation/ Recreation 158 Super Market/ Cargills - Commercial Bo-Trcc andhe Market - Lively/ Colourful Bridge and the surrounding - Openness/Vibrant/ Leisure '• * Sumangala Girl's School * Church Station - Gathering Library ASP Bungalow - History Water Body/ Hudson Park - Openness Kethumathi - History Big Houses with spacious Gardens - 77istoryf Social Background o Buddha Statue (Horana Road) - Religion Ugly/ Boring Areas, Elements, Features and their Significant Characteristics • Private Bus Stand - Dirty/Noisy • Market - Dirty/ Congested/ Unpleasant/ Smelly e Area Around Fish Market - Dirty/ Congested/ Unpleasant/ Smelly • Modarawila - Waste Dump « Hudson Park - Degraded Envimnment • Beach - Polluted/And Social Activities » Old Dilapidated Buildings - Visually Unpleasant o Shanty areas Along the Beach - Haphazard Development/ Disorder/Anti Social activities o Street in front of Panadura Balika- Disorderly/Anti Social Activities o CTB Bus Stand - Ugly/Stressful/Disorderly o Public Drains - Ugly o Area in front of Rankoth Viharaya - Degraded Environment o Area Surrounding the Estuary - Shanty Development o Pinwatta Area - Shanties/Haphazard Development/ Congested Environment 159 o Panadura Grocery ad the Surrounding Built Fabric - Dilapidated Buildings o Janapriya Mawatha - Congestion/ Disharmony o Railway Station - Disotganized/Lack of Maintenance o Clock Tower - I^ack of Maintenance o Town Hall - AtoV Used Well o Film Hall - Lack of Maintenance o CWE - Not Used Well 09 Prominent Daily Activities and Areas, Elements, and times associated with them o Chanting Pirith - Rankoth Viharaya - Early Morning o Starting Busses - Bus Stand - 5.00 a. m o Movement of School / Office Traffic - Bus Stand/ Railway Station and surrounding areas - Morning and Evening o Opening of Shops - 9.30 a.m o Evening Marketing and Shopping - Janapriya Mawatha/ Market and surroundings o Modara Fishing - Mornings and Evenings o Fighting - CTB Bus Stand o Gathering in the Beach Evenings (Specially Weekends) o People Visiting the Hospital - Especially 11.30 a.m - 1.30 p.m and 4.30 p.m - 6.30 p.m 10 Prominent Seasonal Activities and Areas, Elements and Times associated with them o Vesak/ Poson Perahera - Galle Road o Independents Day Celebration - Galle Road o Katina Perhera - October o Vesak Celebration - Town Hall, Market, Janpiy Mawta,GalleRoad o Trade Fain? - GallRoad, Twn Hall Gardens o Political Meetings o New Year Festivities - Janapriya Mawatha, Town Hall, Galle Road * * * * * * * * * * : * * * * * * * * • * * * * 06% 08% 56% 10% 24% 10% 08% 08% 08% 16% 14% 160 18% Musical Shows - Private Bus Stand, School Grounds, Town Hall o Gammadu Festival o Christmas Festivities - Town Hall, Janapriya Mawatha, Galle Road Buddhist Centre Activities Prominent Current Problem o Transport Problem (Both Road Network and Transportation) o Sanitary Problems o Flooding of Certain Areas o Garbage Dumping Overflowing Drains Pollution of Water Pollution of the Beach Antisocial Activities Lack of Space for public Activities Pavement Hawkers (Janapriya Mawqwatha and Surroundings) Bad Condition of Roads and Streets Traffic Congestion Lots of Accidents Parking Problems Congested Built Environment Lack of Connectivity Uncontrollable Spreading of Town Too Much Segregation of Activities Absence of Centre Water Supply Problems Musical Shows Disorganized and Unclean environments - Private and CTB Bus Stands, Park, etc; Parts of the Town Frequently Visited and the Reason o Temple (Rankoth Viharaya) - Religious Food City - Shopping Panadura Grocers - Shopping Janapriya Mawatha - Marketing / Shoping Bus Stand - Transport/ Idling Railway Station - Transport Market - Marketing * * * * * * * * * * * * « * * * * * * OT 14% 08% 20% 08% 18% 14% 12% 10% 08% 06% 06% 06% 18% 08% 10% 12% 18% 12% 10% Deshani - Functional Need/Quality Environment 161 30% o Devon Bakers - unctionalNeed Quality Environment * o Sumangala Balika - Education o St. Anthony's Col lege - Educational Play Ground - Recreational, Gathering Would Like to Visit o Beach - Freedom/ Windy/ belter Quality Areas you would dislike to Visit o Market - Polluted/ Ugly e Bus Stand - Unclean/Crowded/unpleasant o Railway Station Surroundings - Unclean/ cwwded/ Unpleasant o Road in front of Panadura Balika - Drunkards and Odd characters o Main Stree - Congested and Polluted * Beach - Relaxation/ Gathering : Banks - Functional Need * Shed - Functional Need : * ASB- Functional need * Hospital Juncton Commercial Area (Galle Road) - Functional Need Temple (Rankoth Viharaya) - Freedom/ ; Serenity : * Space in front of Walana Buddha Statue - Serenity . * Road Leading Towards Anglican Church - Quiet/less Traffic . * Janapriya Mawatha - Vivid Character * Old gale Road - Vivid Character * New bridge and the surroundings - Quiet / Relaxing/ Openness \ * West End of the Main Street - low Scale, Humane Environment * Market - Vivid Character * Shops : * Old Road Passing Kethumathie/Courts - Greenety/ Quiet/ Less Traffic * Cargills - Shopping, Quality Environment . * Commercial Area - Functional Needs •. * Hudson Park : * Railway Bridge River and Surroundings Railway Station Public Play Ground f£2 Near Panadura Bus Stand and around the Bo- Tree - Traffic congestion, haphazard parking, blocked Drains, garbage Etc; Kovil and the Surroundings - Gloomy, Disorderly Environment Old Galle Road - Too Commercialized and Congested Dispensary - Crowded Beach - Unclean Elements/Locations/A reas/Fcatu res/Events to be prcscrvcdO • Beach - most entertaining » Buddha statue (vVa\ana)-Symbol/Identity » Bo-tree at private bus stand -symbol/identity Markcl-Location good Historical temples - History Shopping Areas - Functional Private Bus Stand - Good Location, Better Accessibility Gunnanda Statue - Identity Clock Tower - Landmark Old Houses - History Old Galle Road-History Shopping Activities (Janapriya Mawathsa, Galle Road) - Accessibility Main Street - Functionally Significant Rankoth Viharaya - Identity/History/ landmark Town Hall - Historical Significance Play Ground - Good Location, Functional Significance Church - Landmark Roundabout - Landmark Food City - Functional Significance CTB Bus Stand - Location Good Railway Station - Location Good Historical Significance Hospital - Location good Market - Location Good Courts Complex - Location Good Empty Lands within the Town - Open Spaces Urban Council - -Location Good Kovil - Religious Buddhist Centre - Religious Panadura Debate Grounds - History Police Station - Location Good Post Office - Location Good Banks - Location good * * * * * * * * * * * * * * 163 Elements/ Locations/ Areas/ Features/ Events to be changed/ Modified o Market - Dirty/Unclean/ Unpleasant o CTB Stand - Congestion/Dirty/Disorder o Sewerage System - Malfunctioning/ Lack of Maintenance o Road/ Transport System - Disorder/ Congestion o Garbage Disposal System - Malfunctioning/ Unpleasant o Hudson Park - Polluted/Neglected/dead © Beach and the surroundings - Poorly organized/somewhat unclean/need more social security o Street facades - Disorder/Lack of Maintenance/Disharmony e Private stand - Congestion /Dirty/ Disorder Commercial areas - Disorder/Disharmony Rankoth Vihara Surroundings - Disorder/ Disharmony/ Degradation Estuary and the Surroundings - underutilized/ Degraded Clock Tower and the Surroundings - Potential to be Developed as a centre Cinema Halls . * Musical Shows * Shanty Areas . * Open Space (Town Hall Premises, Play Ground, Hudson Park, Water Body) - Underutilized/ Poorly Organized and maintained . * Boundary Walls along the Main Road - Unsightly/ Disinteresting •• * Marketing/ Shopping Facilities - disorganized . * Railway Station - Weakly inked with the other Transport Terminals Janapriya Mawatha - Too Congested Drainage Problems Old Gale Road — Disharmony/ Disorder Lack of Greenery Elements/ Locations/ Areas/ Features/ Events which are not fully Utilized o Public Ground/ Town Hall/ and Surroundings o Hudson Park * o Rankoth Viharaya nd Surroundings o Library o Hospital and Surroundings o Station Approach Road/ Kovil 1 6 4 Station and Surroundings Marine and River Activities Beach and Surroundings o Buddha Mandiraya © Links Between Railway Stauon and the Bus Stand o Seasonal Cultural Activities o Janapriya Mawatha • Market Place o Post Office a Service Stations o Food City o Shopping Areas o CWE Premises » Clock Tower and Surroundings Changes In Panadura Town — Past Year o Development of Large Scale Shopping Complexes and technical Support Buildings Especially Along Galle Road © More Industrial Activity o Renovations of Private Bus Stand o Road renovations/ Widening of Roundabouts o No Significant Changes o Development Near Hospital © Town Centre Shifted Towards Moratuwa o Occupation/ Utilization of Bare land o Buddhist Centre Development © New Library o Improvement of Public Services Changes in Panadura Town - Past 5 Years © Revival of Road and Lighting System © Rapid Development of Diverse Commercial Activities o Improvements to Transport Systems © More Medical facilities © New Banking facilities © Three Wheeler Services o Development of Garment Industry © Development along Galle Road From Bus Stand towards Walana o Improvements to the Market © Increase of Intensity of Human Activity © Widening of and Improvements to Galle Road © Improvements to Panadura Base Hospital © Bus Stand and Surrounding © Cosmopolitan Crowd 16% 06% 22% 18% * * * * * * * * * 06% 48% 08% * * * 24% 06% 08% 16% Variety of Business Enterprises Expected Future of the Panadura Town • Improvement of all service Activities and Related Spaces * : * o More Large Scale Commercial Buildings will ; come up (Especially along the Gale Road) o Rapid Development of Housing * . o Clean City * * © Well Organized Transport System : * : * : * * • Well Organized Garbage Disposal and Drainage System ; * ; © Changing the Nature of Commercial Activities * ; * e Upliftment of Educational Activities ;* i * ® A Reorganization of Town Centre \ * . * • Shifting of CTB Bus Stand * * • Well Organized and Maintained Market ; * ; * • Good Network of Public Spaces !* ; * o Improvements to Significant Places and their Surroundings o More Hygienic Town » Development to Station and Surroundings • Modifications to the Two Bus Stands o Improvements to Janapriya Mawatha to Reduce the Congestion » Improvements to the Hospital o Less traffic i * » Concentration of Activities in the Town Centre \* o Improved Twon Centre '• * © More Housing Schemes : * <» Increase of Population ; * Characteristics of your Ideal Town » Proper Bus Stand <» Spaciousness/ Openness o Sanitary Facilities • Good Shopping/ Marketing Facilities o Better Educational, Health and Recreational Activities o Cleanliness/ Pollution Free o Transportation Facilities o High Standard Consumer Facilities o Not Noisy <» Road Network with Guiding Landmarks * • Security • Modernized Town i * ; * * * * : * * : * * * * * * : * * * O Presence of a Centre * 166 Orderliness Good Smelling Presence of Meaningful Landmarks Accessibility Properly Designed and Planned town Less Congestion A Good Interactive Place Having Specific Areas for Specific Buildings and Elements City with a Garden A Living City More Greenery Proper Garbage Disposal System Cohesiveness Pleasant and Attractive Place 10%